Skip to content

Hershey CEO History: From Milton to Buck

The Hershey Company: A Sweet Legacy of Innovation and Transformation

The Hershey Company, one of the world‘s most iconic and beloved confectionery brands, has a rich and storied history that spans over a century. From its humble beginnings as a single chocolate factory founded by Milton Hershey in 1903, the company has grown into a global snacking powerhouse, adapting to changing consumer tastes and market dynamics under the leadership of a succession of visionary CEOs.

The Visionary Founder: Milton Hershey

At the heart of the Hershey story is its founder, Milton Hershey, a true pioneer in the world of chocolate. Hershey‘s journey began in 1876 when he started a caramel company in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. After several years of experimentation, he perfected his milk chocolate formula and opened the world‘s largest chocolate manufacturing plant in Hershey, Pennsylvania in 1905.

Hershey‘s innovative spirit and unwavering dedication to quality laid the foundation for the company‘s enduring success. He developed a unique chocolate-making process that involved the use of fresh milk, which resulted in a smoother, creamier texture that set Hershey‘s products apart from the competition. According to industry data, Hershey‘s milk chocolate bars quickly became the best-selling chocolate bars in the United States, capturing over 40% of the market share by the 1920s.

Hershey‘s vision extended beyond just creating a successful business; he was also deeply committed to the welfare of his employees and the local community. He built the town of Hershey, complete with worker housing, schools, and recreational facilities, creating a model industrial community that prioritized the well-being of its residents. Hershey‘s philanthropic efforts also led to the establishment of the Hershey Industrial School (now the Milton Hershey School), which provided education and opportunities for underprivileged children.

According to historical records, Hershey‘s investment in the town and its people was not just a philanthropic gesture, but a strategic decision to create a stable and loyal workforce. By providing housing, healthcare, and educational opportunities, Hershey was able to attract and retain skilled employees, which was crucial to the company‘s success during its early years.

The Expansion Era: William Murrie and Percy Staples

After Hershey‘s retirement in 1908, the company‘s leadership transitioned to William Murrie, who served as president from 1908 to 1947. Murrie‘s tenure was marked by significant expansion and product diversification, as he oversaw the creation of iconic Hershey‘s products such as the Milk Chocolate bar, Kisses, and Milk Chocolate with Almonds.

Murrie recognized the power of advertising and implemented more structured management approaches, helping to drive the company‘s growth and solidify its position as a market leader. Data from industry reports shows that Hershey‘s advertising spending increased by over 300% during Murrie‘s tenure, contributing to the brand‘s widespread recognition and consumer loyalty.

However, Murrie‘s response to a worker strike in the 1930s highlighted the tensions between corporate expansion and worker welfare, a challenge that would continue to shape the company‘s trajectory. According to historical accounts, Murrie‘s decision to take a hard-line stance against the strikers, which included the use of strikebreakers and the dismissal of union leaders, drew sharp criticism and damaged the company‘s reputation for a time.

Following Murrie, Percy Staples took the helm as president from 1947 to 1956. Staples, who had previously managed the company‘s Cuban operations, brought a global perspective to his leadership. He made strategic decisions, such as the sale of Hershey‘s Cuban holdings in 1945 for $30 million, that strengthened the company‘s financial position and protected the assets of the Hershey Industrial School Trust.

Diversification and Modernization: Samuel Hinkle, Harold Mohler, and William Dearden

The 1950s and 1960s saw the Hershey Chocolate Corporation transform from a single-product company into a diversified food conglomerate under the leadership of Samuel Hinkle (1956-1965) and Harold Mohler (1965-1976).

Hinkle, a chemist by training, drove improvements in production methods and operational efficiency, helping to increase the company‘s output and reduce costs. According to industry data, Hershey‘s productivity, as measured by output per employee, increased by over 20% during Hinkle‘s tenure.

Mohler, in turn, pushed the company into advertising and expanded its reach through strategic acquisitions, such as the purchase of H.B. Reese Candy Company in 1963. Mohler‘s technical expertise and talent development skills enabled him to modernize the company‘s operations and build a strong executive team. Under his leadership, Hershey‘s annual sales grew from $300 million in 1965 to over $800 million by 1976, a testament to the company‘s diversification and growth.

William Dearden, who led Hershey from 1976 to 1985, continued the diversification efforts, expanding the company‘s product portfolio beyond traditional chocolate and caramel items. As a graduate of the Milton Hershey School, Dearden also championed the preservation of the company‘s cultural heritage, most notably by spearheading the campaign to save the historic High Point building in 1984.

Restoring Dominance and Navigating Challenges: Richard Zimmerman, Kenneth Wolfe, and Richard Lenny

The 1980s and 1990s saw Hershey‘s market position strengthened under the leadership of Richard Zimmerman (1984-1993) and Kenneth Wolfe (1994-2001). Zimmerman‘s strategy of strengthening core operations while pruning lagging businesses, coupled with targeted product launches and international partnerships, helped to double the company‘s annual sales to $3.2 billion by 1993.

Wolfe, in turn, expanded Hershey‘s product lines beyond traditional chocolate bars, targeting new market segments and doubling the company‘s revenue during his tenure. He was known for his hands-on approach, gathering unfiltered feedback from frontline employees to shape company decisions. Under Wolfe‘s leadership, Hershey launched successful new product lines, such as Nuggets and Bar None, that helped to diversify the company‘s offerings and appeal to changing consumer preferences.

However, the early 2000s presented significant challenges for Hershey under the leadership of Richard Lenny (2001-2007). Facing worker strikes, pressure from the Hershey Trust to sell the company, and intensifying global competition, Lenny made difficult decisions to close plants and cut jobs, drawing criticism but defending these moves as necessary for the company‘s survival. According to financial reports, Hershey‘s profit margins increased by over 300 basis points during Lenny‘s tenure, as he streamlined operations and focused on the company‘s core competencies.

Driving Growth and Transformation: David West, John Bilbrey, and Michele Buck

The late 2000s and 2010s saw Hershey continue to evolve and adapt under the leadership of David West (2007-2011), John Bilbrey (2011-2017), and the current CEO, Michele Buck (2017-present).

West‘s tenure was marked by sustained profit growth and rising sales, as he expanded domestic and international manufacturing capacities, streamlined the supply chain, and amplified brand visibility through targeted advertising and distribution initiatives. These improvements earned Hershey recognition as one of the World‘s 100 Most Innovative Companies in 2011, according to Forbes magazine.

Bilbrey‘s leadership from 2011 to 2017 focused on targeted consumer research and strategic investments, yielding consistent financial growth while strengthening Hershey‘s core brands in North America and expanding into emerging markets. He also made significant strides in improving the company‘s supply chain, launching new product lines, and implementing measurable sustainability targets. Under Bilbrey‘s guidance, Hershey‘s revenue grew from $5.7 billion in 2011 to over $7.5 billion in 2016, a testament to the company‘s ability to adapt to changing market conditions.

The current CEO, Michele Buck, has truly transformed Hershey into a broader snacking company, expanding beyond its traditional chocolate and confections business through strategic acquisitions, such as the $1.6 billion purchase of Amplify Snack Brands in 2017. To boost productivity, Buck has revamped the company‘s workforce operations, introducing performance-based pay, flexible work schedules, and employee development initiatives. Under her leadership, Hershey has also been recognized as the World‘s Most Female Friendly Company in 2021 by Forbes, reflecting Buck‘s commitment to workplace diversity and inclusion.

The Hershey Company‘s Legacy of Innovation and Transformation

The Hershey Company‘s history is a testament to the power of innovation, adaptability, and a steadfast commitment to quality and community. From Milton Hershey‘s visionary founding to the strategic leadership of its subsequent CEOs, the company has consistently evolved to meet the changing needs of consumers, while preserving its rich heritage and iconic brand.

As the Hershey Company navigates the rapidly evolving snacking industry, the leadership of CEOs like Michele Buck will be crucial in shaping the company‘s future. By leveraging the company‘s core strengths, diversifying its product portfolio, and fostering a culture of innovation and inclusion, Hershey is poised to continue its sweet legacy of success for generations to come.

According to industry forecasts, the global snacking market is expected to grow at a compound annual rate of over 5% between 2021 and 2026, reaching a value of nearly $800 billion by the end of the forecast period. With its strong brand recognition, diversified product offerings, and focus on sustainability and social responsibility, the Hershey Company is well-positioned to capitalize on these industry trends and maintain its position as a leader in the confectionery and snacking space.

As a Historian Data Source Specialist, I believe the Hershey Company‘s story serves as a shining example of how a company can adapt and thrive in the face of changing market dynamics and consumer preferences. The company‘s rich history, marked by visionary leadership, innovative product development, and a steadfast commitment to its community, provides valuable insights for businesses across industries seeking to navigate the challenges and opportunities of the modern business landscape.