Choosing Your Path: Assessing College Majors in Today‘s Job Market
Hey there! As you probably know first-hand, deciding on a college major can be downright agonizing. I sure remember staring at that course catalog and wondering “What’s going to happen if I choose the wrong thing?” It’s easy to second-guess ourselves when the pundits and news headlines seem to proclaim a new “useless major” every week.
But here’s the deal — no area of study that captivates human curiosity and creativity is truly useless. Every discipline adds threads to the grand tapestry of culture and knowledge. Of course, I realize it’s about more than that when you have to, you know, eat and pay rent after graduation! Practical concerns around jobs and earnings do matter when assessing majors. However, value can’t be reduced to a dollar figure either.
So rather than buying into sensational claims about certain majors being hopeless dead-ends, I want to have an honest, caring conversation about your educational options. My goal is to provide some grounded perspective and constructive advice so you can make the most empowered choice. Not the most lucrative necessarily, but the one aligning with your interests and appetite for some friendly risk-taking!
I don’t pretend to have all the answers, but as an education reformer focused on student welfare and outcomes, I’ve done my homework on this stuff. I’ll be upfront about challenges some graduates face while offering an optimistic game plan for adapting and succeeding, not just discouraging words. Deal? Super, let’s get to it!
The Lay of the Land — Understanding Today‘s Job Market
As you’ve likely heard, the job market continues evolving in some fascinating ways thanks to economic and technological forces. Unique opportunities are emerging alongside persistent challenges. Unemployment for recent grads actually dropped below 4% in 2018 , lower than the national average. So fears about mass shortages of good jobs seem overblown.
However, underemployment remains an issue. Over 40% of recent grads are estimated to be underutilized in jobs not requiring a college degree. Competition is also fierce for coveted positions in growing fields like software engineering or data science. Salaries and benefits lag in other traditionally creative fields like fine arts and counseling. Saturation can even affect previously “safe” majors like business if candidates lack the right experience.
Plus, employer needs are rapidly changing. Demand is rising for hybrid, technical skills alongside the communication and critical thinking abilities that liberal arts disciplines cultivate (and that robots still lack!). Values like diversity, sustainability and creativity increasingly impact hiring too. More students respond by double majoring or pursuing graduate training for versatility.
So a nuanced assessment of majors in this context involves checking your assumptions about “useless” degrees while bringing realistic questions about specific tradeoffs and opportunities. Your interests may face uneven job prospects, earning potential or demands, but with pragmatism and some hustle, meaningful work can absolutely be found. Let’s unpack things further!
Majors Facing Uphill Climbs — The Reality
You’ve likely seen lists of purportedly “useless” majors floating around that liberal arts champions then defend by celebrating philosopher bartenders or some such. Well, as an avid learner, I applause a broad education, yet also believe ethically in acknowledging economic realities many graduates encounter. So while no field is monolithically “useless,” the pragmatic truth is that prospects in certain disciplines are decidedly mixed.
Surveys of long-term outcomes consistently show graduates of performing/fine arts, theology, philosophy, communication, anthropology and niche cultural studies facing high unemployment rates or chronically low earnings akin blue-collar work. Average mid-career salaries in these areas often land below $50k. Fields like sociology, journalism, English, film studies and general arts/humanities also show uneven outcomes, especially if graduates don‘t build marketing savvy and technical breadth.
And while psychologists can absolutely practice with a relevant Master‘s, at the Bachelor‘s level, limited opportunities beyond research roles does frustrate many, although skills transfer well to sales or coordinating gigs. Can we please ditch false dichotomies of “do what you love” versus "chasing coin” too? Most sane people want a degree injecting meaning plus adequate economic freedom.
So yes, the data suggests certain majors present real tradeoffs. That may be fine for trust-fund kids unconcerned about earnings potential! But loans must be repaid. I believe ethically that college should improve socioeconomic opportunity beyond what high school offers. If astronomical tuition instead chains graduates to years of strained finances due to nearly useless degrees mismatching job needs, something is amiss.
Of course, these majors still hold significance for scholarship and culture! I adore philosophers and poets too, don’t get me wrong! We need their big ideas and beautiful expressions. Creative fields just often run at an economic loss individually, requiring patronage or alternative value generation akin to ecosystems services. This truth should be transparent so students can plan realistically around income needs and fallback options.
Empowering Learners — Understanding Your Priorities
Frankly, traditional college may not even be the best pathway to entry for many vocational creative fields, from dance and theater to design and music production. Hands-on training and portfolio building matters most. Sky-high tuition for standard theory courses of uncertain economic value to individuals makes little sense when alternatives exist.
But that reveals the importance of knowing yourself and clarifying priorities for what constitutes a “successful” degree. This means reflecting on a few questions:
• How interested are you in study for its own sake vs transitioning seamlessly into a career?
• Do you need your education to provide middle-class baseline earnings or prefer following artistic passions despite lower pay?
• How risk tolerant are you around job uncertainty and length of career establishment?
• Are you pursuing areas with clear licensing/credentialing needs for jobs like clinical counseling?
• How entrepreneurial and proactive are you about continually upskilling, networking and self-marketing?
There are no right answers per se. Different types of people thrive on distinct paths. Creators able to live lightly may feel stifled in corporate roles no matter the splendid pay and prestige to others. Some derive their meaning more from family or community participation rather than work achievement. Asking these questions invites you to clarify the lifestyle and security you envision needing then working backwards.
Certain traditional majors still prove lucrative like engineering, economics, data analytics and nursing. But income statistics can mislead when vocational synergies exist. Say between environmental policy and law. Or anthropology and human-centered design. Keep an open, curious, interdisciplinary mindset. Having a good job need not mean donning a suit and squeezing into a cubicle either, especially as more companies support telecommuting. Beyond salaries, consider whether careers match your temperament, values and idea of success.
Taking Realistic, Empowered Action
No educational choice precludes you from creating personal and professional fulfillment on some level. But majors differ in how smooth and straight that road appears based on economic indicators. Optimism need not imply naivety. However, students willing to flexibly evolve across sectors and take proactive responsibility for continually bettering their situation access the most possibilities.
Rather than being afraid of the “wrong” choice, empower yourself by planning resilience into your education. Seek versatility. Keep gathering useful knowledge and skills from online learning platforms like Coursera or LinkedIn Learning too. Connect in-person through professional associations and passionate maker-spaces. Build only forward momentum.
If debts are piling up from high tuition with few job leads, pause enrollment until securing income then strategically earn credits from cheaper programs aligning with workforce needs. No law says clutching a provisional philosophy degree means resigning yourself to lifelong barista status rather than pivoting into other education then thriving in a completely different field!
Consider your passion through multiple lenses then get creative blending titles and roles to construct uniquely fulfilling livelihoods. Social entrepreneurship and small business ventures blend meaning with income generation. Partner dynamically with those offering complementary abilities like tech platform development. Seek niches underserved in outdated institutions and markets. Build tribe, take action.
The Bottom Line
While sometimes informing students about economic realities feels akin to informing them Santa isn’t real, truth spurs growth. I don’t view any disciplines as intrinsically “useless”—our proliferating, elective course catalogues demonstrates the bounty of human curiosity! Yet ignoring clear statistical trends around employability, salaries and job satisfaction post-graduation does naive learners a disservice too.
Arm yourself with eyes wide open about the modern job market then get creative responding to its ever-evolving nature. This adaptable readiness proves most valuable whether you pick a major considered “solid” or “squishy.” After all, even the most technical skills face disruption over decades-long careers.
Stay open, keep your options fluid, choose something aligning with your temperament and values, then handle the twists and turns with responsiveness. Learning enables opportunity. Optimizing your major for the current environment need not lock you in permanently or dictate an entire identity either. This liberation should bring some peace!
You’ve got this! Now go rock it, [insert preferred name], you hot mess of potential!
%20–%20Save%20Our%20Schools%20March){kind=link}